Funny Propositions

  • Funny Propositions  
  • Reviewed by Tim Treanor

 For about ten minutes, this Fine Wine Players production is as good as anything in the Fringe. Very cool music, full of synthesizers and tubas, floats out of hidden speakers. Amanda Puskar, all curls and greasepaint and raccoon eyes, silently hands out the programs.

Then the play begins.

Really, why would anyone do this? Playwright Ann James gives us four Twilight Zone-themed stories. One of them, in which an ambitious news reporter (Ashley Morgaine Lowe) interviews a widow who collects dolls (Marilyn Bennett, who also produces) has some potential, if the clunky exposition at the end is excised and the dialogue otherwise sharpened. The other three are pointless, incomprehensible or both.

The acting is graceless, hammy and underprepared. An actor must deliver his lines as though he just thought of the words; these guys delivered their lines as though they were trying to visualize the script they had in their hands ten minutes before the performance opened. Indeed, most community theater I’ve seen puts better actors on the stage, and would consider a production like this to be a failure. I was surprised in reading the bios to discover that some of the performers have worked with Scena, which periodically does good stuff.

The Fine Wine Players appear to be dedicated to putting the mature actor on stage.  I think that’s a great idea, but there’s more to being a theater company than simply declaring yourself one. Fine Wine would have been better advised to take the money which they used to pay for a Fringe entry and use it to help pay for training and development instead. That way, they could have put on a Fringe-worthy show in 2009, instead of this unfortunate mess.

I specifically exempt the adorable Ms. Puskar from all of these criticisms. To be fair, though, she didn’t have many lines, and appears to be about seven years old.

  • Running time: 45 minutes
  • Tickets:  Funny Propositions
  • Remaining Shows:  Wed, July 23 at 6:30 . Sat, July 26 at 3 . Sun, July 27 at 3
  • Where:  Goethe Institute, 812 7th Street, NW
Tim Treanor About Tim Treanor

Tim Treanor Senior Writer, member, DCTS Board of Directors. Since 2005, Tim has written over 500 reviews and numerous news articles, features and interviews for DCTS. He is a member of the American Theater Critics Association and sits on its New Plays committees. He is also a fellow of the National Critics Institute, run by the O’Neill Theater Center. His interactive murder mystery, Murder in Elsinore, enjoyed a brief run in 2003; another play, Dracula. A Love Story. ran in the 2014 Capital Fringe Festival. His novel, The Seduction of Braulio Jules, is available on Amazon. By day he is a trial lawyer for the Federal government. He lives with his dear bride, Lorraine, in a log house in the woods of Southern Maryland. For more Tim Treanor, go to


  1. I can admit that I don’t catch many- make that any theater events in DC these days, however, I don’t think this production was quite that bad. There were some really funny parts. While I agree more work could have been done, I feel this is overly harsh. In the past I have seen worse things from Professional acting groups. I think they did a good job with an “interesting” script. At the end of the day, most actors won’t be superstars. But don’t attempt to spare us the best part of theater………the lab.

    Besides, there can only be so many Simon Cowells in the world. Spare us that…



Anti-Spam Quiz:

Reprint Policy Our articles may not be reprinted in full but only as excerpts and those portions may only be used if a credit and link is provided to our website.
DC Theatre Scene is supported in part by the DC Commission on the Arts & Humanities and by the Humanities Council of Washington, DC.