For the South of Evan Linder’s play Byhalia, Mississippi, both the American flag and the Confederate one should be replaced by one reading “Bless This Mess.” It’s racist, classist, misogynist, and crude—but it’ll muddle through somehow.

Can we forgive personal, historical, and political trespasses? That is the defining question. At one point, the heroine, Laurel (an earthily charming Caroline Neff), says that her new rules will be to love and to tell the truth. That’s a beautiful notion for a fundamentally beautiful character and it makes the bittersweet work, in a well-produced and energetically acted production at the Kennedy Center’s Terrace Theater, go down more easily, like Sam Shepard on Prozac.
[adsanity_rotating align=”aligncenter” time=”10″ group_id=”1455″ /]
It doesn’t have Shepard’s dry mythical sweep or the quirky, intricate characterizations of a deeper, more sophisticated and satisfying household-in-hell drama, Tracy Letts’s August: Osage County. Linder’s is a Grim America Lite. That makes the work palatable (and popular), but also limits it. It’s social commentary that simultaneously soothes the heartburn—Jack Daniels with a splash of Pepto Bismol.
Linder refreshingly undermines some stereotypes. For instance, Laurel’s husband, Jim (a playful and vulnerable Jack Falahee), ain’t the unfeeling red-neck construction worker you might at first take him to be, and his African-American childhood pal Karl (a ruggedly capricious Blake Morris) has a weird thing for Tammy Wynette. Linder also gives lively particulars and nuance to other clichés, like Laurel’s bulldozing hellfire-spouting fundamentalist Dixie momma, Celeste (a terrifying and occasionally hilarious Cecelia Wingate), and the successful African-American Junior League do-gooder, Ayesha (an electric Aimé Donna Kelly), who is so tensely proper that she could clearly combust at any minute.

But whether he’s parkouring off or jumping over our Southern gothic expectations, Linder is a somewhat too evident author ex machina. Every plot development or underlined insult feels like a plastic trigger for characters to have a self-revelation, then launch into a ferocious or pitiful monologue in which they let down their mask and shed light on what’s really going on in this alien, redolent realm called Mississippi.
The script is crafty and well packaged, and surely touches on a slew of hot-button issues, but there’s something predictably unpredictable about it, and at least one character’s sudden about-face in the second act feels especially artificial. The light moments often rest on reliable scatological riffs about porn or childbirth or farts during sex. Those interludes let the cast verge on breaking character and allow the audience to reset after whatever bigoted or sexist spasm came before, but they feel cheap.
Byhalia, Mississippi closes July 7, 2019 at The Kennedy Center . Details and tickets
Under the direction of Kimberly Senior, the work’s most believable element is Laurel’s relationship with her mom, Celeste. There, Linder lets filial craziness speak its elemental truths. The pair’s “I love yous” sting and their hate steams with an unbreakable, unspeakable devotion. After conveying that they’ll never talk to each other again, there’s the follow-up: “Call me when you get there.”

Like the South itself in Linder’s take, the women are hopeless and unstoppable, headed for hell and heaven on the same rough patch of road.
Byhalia, Mississippi by Evan Linder, at the Terrace Theater of the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts. Executive producer: Jeffrey Finn. Director: Kimberly Senior. Starring Jack Falahee, Aime Donna Kelly, Blake Morris, Caroline Neff, and Cecelia Wingate. Scenic design: Cameron Anderson. Costume design: Jen Caprio. Lighting design: Jennifer Reiser. Sound design: Mikhail Fiksel. Production stage manager: Megan Schwartz Dickert. Fight director: Dav Anzuelo. Technical director: Glenn Turner. General manager: Monica Holt. Assistant producer: Kassie Lewis. Reviewed by Alexander C. Kafka.
A very well-written review, and I agree with it. I went to the 6/15/19 performance and I wish that I had those hours of my life back. Wingate was excellent, but the rest of the cast ranged from passable to poor. The script itself is repetitive and wants to be too many things at once: comedy, personal family drama, or civil rights docudrama. It fails at all of them. It was disappointing.